Your daily connection to the Land of Israel



The Ninth of Av: Throwing the Keys Up to Heaven

The Temple Mount in ancient times. (Photo: Arise and Ascend)

The Temple Mount in ancient times. (Photo: Arise and Ascend)

When offering words of comfort to a mourner we reference the destruction of the Temple. The traditional invocation expresses our wish that the mourner be comforted “among the mourners of Zion and Jerusalem”.

It is generally understood that the two are connected because they both represent intense sadness and great loss.

Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik teaches a deeper message by interpreting the following Talmudic story:

When the Babylonian army attacked Israel they also had their eye on destroying the most precious place for the Jews. On the 9th of Av they burned down the first Temple in Jerusalem. At that tragic time the young priests climbed up to the top of the roof  of the Temple and threw the Temple keys up in the air, saying, “Master of the Universe! Since we have not been true custodians, we return the keys to You!” At that moment, a heavenly hand, as it were, came down and took the keys”. (Talmud Taanit 29a)

banner rebuild temple mt

Rabbi Soloveitchik suggested a unique and uplifting insight: The reason God took back the keys was to eventually return them to us. The priests returned the keys to God in order that He hold them in safekeeping and have them readily accessible when the time would come to reopen the gates. Placing the keys in God’s hands symbolizes the hope – and the great faith – that the Temple would surely be rebuilt once again.

The Jewish people have never given up on the great dream of a magnificent future.  God has never given up on that dream either; the keys were not lost, they are securely protected.

In the same way, by referencing the destruction of Temple to the mourner, we delicately express to the mourner a theme of hope and rebuilding. We want the mourner to know that the ‘keys’ always remain in the hand of God and will be used again in a future time. A time will soon come when the door will be unlocked for the bereaved and for all who have suffered. We will be blessed to see a new day which will bring redemption, and with it, comfort and peace.

Rabbi Aaron Goldscheider received his rabbinic ordination from Yeshiva University in 1993 where he also studied Jewish philosophy. Since then he has devoted his life to teaching Torah. For the past twenty years he has served as a synagogue rabbi in Florida and in New York. Currently he is affiliated with the In Our Hearts Project (,), a resource to help families in the Jewish community who have lost children.

This article has 2 comments

  1. Thoris

    I believe that G_d so protected the temple and its location that soon will be verified. Please read TEMPLE by Robert Cornuke. Thus the location has been protected and is readily available for rebuilding.

    • Jeff


      I’ve just started reading the book and have seen the documentary based on it.

      The archeological evidence alone was very convincing. Maybe we will have the third Temple sooner than we hope!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *